Lost and found in translation_Chmutina et al_accepted.pdf (271.19 kB)
Download file

Lost (and found?) in translation: Key terminology in disaster studies

Download (271.19 kB)
journal contribution
posted on 08.12.2020, 08:53 by Ksenia ChmutinaKsenia Chmutina, Neil Sadler, Jason von Meding, Amer Abukhalaf
Purpose: Disaster Studies has emerged as an international interdisciplinary body of knowledge; however, similarly to other academic disciplines, its terminology is predominantly Anglophone. This paper explores the implications of translating disaster studies terminology, most often theorised in English, into other languages and back.
Design/methodology/approach: We chose six of the most commonly used (as well as debated and contested) terms that are prominent in academic, policy and public discourses: resilience, vulnerability, capacity, disaster, hazard, and risk. These words were translated into 54 languages and the meanings were articulated descriptively in cases where the translation didn’t have exactly the same meaning as the word in English. We then analysed these meanings in order to understand implications of disaster scholars working between dominant and “peripheral” languages.
Findings: Our findings demonstrate that many of the terms so casually used in Disaster Studies in English do not translate easily – or at all, opening the concepts that are encoded in these terms for further interpretation. Moreover, the terms used in disaster studies are not only conceptualised in English but are also tied to an Anglophone approach to research. It is important to consider the intertwined implications that the use of the terminology carries, including the creation of a ‘separate’ language; power vs. communication; and linguistic imperialism.
Originality: Understanding of the meaning (and contestation of meaning) of these terms in English provides an insight into the power relationships between English and the other language. Given the need to translate key concepts from English into other languages, it is important to appreciate their cultural and ideological ‘baggage’.

History

School

  • Architecture, Building and Civil Engineering

Published in

Disaster Prevention and Management: an international journal

Volume

30

Issue

2

Pages

149 - 162

Publisher

Emerald

Version

AM (Accepted Manuscript)

Rights holder

© Emerald

Publisher statement

This paper was accepted for publication in the journal Disaster Prevention and Management: an international journal and the definitive published version is available at https://doi.org/10.1108/DPM-07-2020-0232

Acceptance date

19/11/2020

Publication date

2020-12-04

Copyright date

2020

ISSN

0965-3562

Language

en

Depositor

Dr Ksenia Chmutina Deposit date: 20 November 2020

Usage metrics

Categories

Exports