PacifyingBabel.pdf (12.8 MB)
Download file

Pacifying Babel’s Tower: A scientometric analysis of polycentricity in urban research

Download (12.8 MB)
journal contribution
posted on 04.03.2019, 13:55 by Michiel Van Meeteren, Ate Poorthuis, Ben Derudder, Frank Witlox
It is sometimes claimed that the degree of polycentricity of an urban region influences that region’s competitiveness. However, because of widespread use and policy relevance, the underlying concept of polycentricity has become a ‘stretched concept’ in urban studies. As a result, academic debate on the topic leads to situations reminiscent of Babel’s Tower. This meta-study of the scientific literature in urban studies traces the conceptual stretching of polycentricity using scientometric methods and content analysis. All published studies that either apply the concept directly or cite a work that does, were collected from the Scopus bibliographic database. This resulted in a citation network with over 9000 works and more than 20,000 citations between them. Network analysis and clustering algorithms were used to define the most influential papers in different citation clusters within the network. Subsequently, we employed content analysis to systematically assess the mechanisms associated with the formation of polycentric urban systems in each of these papers. Based on this meta-analysis, we argue that the common categorisation of polycentricity research in intra-urban, inter-urban and inter-regional polycentricity is somewhat misleading. More apt categorisations to understand the origins of polycentricity’s conceptual ambiguity relate to different methodological traditions and geographical contexts in which the research is conducted. Nonetheless, we observe a firm relation across clusters between assessments of polycentricity and different kinds of agglomeration economies. We conclude by proposing a re-conceptualisation of polycentricity based on explicitly acknowledging the variable spatial impact of these different kinds of agglomeration economies.

Funding

This paper draws from research conducted within the Policy Research Centre on Spatial Development, funded by the Flemish Government (Belgium).

History

School

  • Social Sciences

Department

  • Geography and Environment

Published in

Urban Studies

Volume

53

Issue

6

Pages

1278 - 1298

Citation

VAN MEETEREN, M. ... et al, 2015. Pacifying Babel’s Tower: A scientometric analysis of polycentricity in urban research. Urban Studies, 53 (6), pp.1278-1298.

Publisher

SAGE Publications © Urban Studies Journal Limited

Version

AM (Accepted Manuscript)

Publisher statement

This work is made available according to the conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0) licence. Full details of this licence are available at: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/

Publication date

2015

Notes

This paper was published in the journal Urban Studies and the definitive published version is available at https://doi.org/10.1177/0042098015573455.

ISSN

0042-0980

eISSN

1360-063X

Language

en