Spallation of thin films driven by pockets of energy concentration

A hypothesis is made that delamination can be driven by pockets of energy concentration (PECs) in the form of pockets of tensile stress and shear stress on and around the interface between a thin film and a thick substrate, where PECs can be caused by thermal, chemical or other processes. Based on this hypothesis, three analytical mechanical models are developed to predict several aspects of the spallation failure of elastic brittle thin films including nucleation, stable and unstable growth, size of spallation and final kinking off. Both straight-edged and circular-edged spallations are considered. The three mechanical models are established using partition theories for mixed-mode fracture based on classical plate theory, first-order shear-deformable plate theory and full 2D elasticity. Experimental results show that all three of the models predict the initiation of unstable growth and the size of spallation very well; however, only the 2D elasticity-based model predicts final kinking off well. The energy for the nucleation and stable growth of a separation bubble comes solely from the PEC energy on and around the interface, which is ‘consumed’ by the bubble as it nucleates and grows. Unstable growth, however, is driven both by PEC energy and by buckling of the separation bubble. Final kinking off is controlled by the fracture toughness of the interface and the film and the maximum energy stored in the separation bubble. This work will be particularly useful for the study of spallation failure in thermal barrier coating material systems