posted on 2011-01-18, 09:55authored bySamantha Callan
Using a grounded theory approach, two case studies were carried out in large
organisations which have recently implemented family-friendly policies. The studies
asked whether or not cultural change has taken place as a result of the implementation of
these policies. Using Shein's (1992) three level model and definition of culture, attention
was focused on underlying assumptions or 'root' facets of organisational culture (and
conceptual distinctions made between culture, image and identity). After establishing
which facets are present and how they exist in combination with each other, shifts which
have taken place as a direct or indirect result of the introduction of policies were
identified. Especial interest was taken in the way the primacy of work was expressed
through the ideal worker type and the extent to which this type has been replaced by the
integrated worker type (Rapoport et al 2002), which acknowledges that family and other
commitments are as legitimate as occupational demands. Both studies conclude that, as
yet, there have been only slight adjustments in the construction of this ideal worker type
and that employees do not make a permanent shift towards the integrated worker type but
`toggle' between these two types.
Explanations are developed for shifts in other cultural facets, such as the importance of
autonomy, emphases on equality or individuation, sense of entitlement and attitudes to
change. The utility of the notion of purposive cultural change is considered, given that
high levels of anxiety are released when unconscious and shared mental structures are
destabilised in such processes of organizational learning. The merits of a more
evolutionary model are explored