posted on 2011-02-18, 11:40authored byElizabeth K.L. Pummell
The aim of this thesis is to produce a substantive grounded theory of junior-to-senior transition and as a result of this work, to provide knowledge and guidance for coaches, sport psychologists and other personnel supporting young aspirant athletes. Underpinned by a social constructionist philosophy, the research programme was designed to capture
and interpret the social world of the participants and to interpret the perceptions derived from their own lived experience of the transition. The thesis consists of three studies which, in a concatenated programme of research, are
predicated one upon another. In order that understanding in social research can be
advanced, the development of theory requires several rounds of fieldwork, analysis and
publication (Stebbins, 1992,2006). Thus the building of theory took place over the initial
two studies, the first of which involved the in-depth interviewing of nine participants
from individual sports (M age = 24.5 years, S. D. = 4.3 years). As a consequence of this
exercise, rich data were collected, depicting the participants' experiences of the juniorsenior transition. Grounded in these data, a preliminary model of junior-to-senior
transition was constructed using Strauss and Corbin's (1998) guidelines for grounded
theory analysis. More specifically, the resultant model revealed a cyclical process: of
learning, identity development and progress at transition. Inception of the process is
characterised by immersion in the post-transition environment during the pre-transition
phase, in which significant observational learning occurs via the use of more senior role
models. This process leads to the identification of discrepancies between the actual (or
junior) and ideal (or senior) self. This promotes a period of adjustment in which the
behaviours relevant to senior status are incorporated within the self, bringing about a
sense of readiness, or ability to cope with the transition. In essence, the athletes had
sought to structure their pre-transition environment to represent that which they would
encounter post-transition, thereby generating stability for their self-identity. The
modification of identity, through the adjustment of behaviours and roles, predicted a
competitive breakthrough, at which point the athletes began to think about the subsequent
step at senior level, and hence the cycle of immersion, learning and adjustment continued. (Continues...).