Multi-body dynamics analysis and experimental investigations for the determination of the physics of drive train vibro-impact induced elasto-acoustic coupling
A very short and disagreeable audible and tactile response from a vehicle driveline may be excited
when the throttle is abruptly applied or released, or when the clutch is rapidly engaged. The
condition is most noticeable in low gear and in slow moving traffic, when other background engine
and road noise levels are low. This phenomenon is known as clonk and is often associated with the
first cycle of shuffle response, which is a low frequency longitudinal vehicle movement excited by
throttle demand. It is often reported that clonk may coincide with each cycle of the shuffle response,
and multiple clonks may then occur. The problem is aggravated by backlash and wear in the
drivetrain, and it conveys a perception of low quality to the customer.
Hitherto, reported investigations do not reveal or discuss the mechanism and causal factors of clonk
in a quantitative manner, which would relate the engine impulsive torque to the elastic response of
the driveline components, and in particular to the noise radiating surfaces. Crucially, neither have
the issues of sensitivity, variability and non-linearity been addressed and published. It is also of
fundamental importance that clonk is seen as a total system response to impulsive torque, in the
presence of distributed lash at the vibro-elastic impact sites.
In this thesis, the drivetrain is defined as the torque path from the engine flywheel to the road
wheels. The drivetrain is a lightly damped and highly non-linear dynamic system. There are many
impact and noise emitting locations in the driveline that contribute to clonk, when the system is
subjected to shock torque loading.
This thesis examines the clonk energy paths, from the initial impact to many driveline lash
locations, and to the various noise radiating surfaces. Both experimental and theoretical methods are applied to this complex system. Structural and acoustic dynamics are considered, as well as the very important frequency couplings between elastic structures and acoustic volumes.
Preliminary road tests had indicated that the clonk phenomenon was a, very short transient impact
event between lubricated contacts and having a high frequency characteristic. This indicated that a
multi-body dynamics simulation of the driveline, in conjunction with a high frequency elasto-acoustic coupling analysis, would be required. In addition, advanced methods of signal analysis
would be required to handle the frequency content of the very short clonk time histories. These are
the main novelties of this thesis.
There were many successful outcomes from the investigation, including quantitative agreement
between the numerical and experimental investigations. From the experimental work, it was
established that vehicle clonk could be accurately reproduced on a driveline rig and also on a
vehicle chassis dynamometer, under controlled test conditions. It then enabled Design of
Experiments to be conducted and the principal causal factors to be identified. The experimental
input and output data was also used to verify the mathematical simulation. The high frequency FE
analysis of the structures and acoustic cavities were used to predict the dynamic modal response to a
shock input. The excellent correlation between model and empirical data that was achieved, clearly
established the clonk mechanism in mathematical physics terms. Localised impact of meshing gears
under impulsive loads were found to be responsible for high frequency structural wave propagation,
some of which coupled with the acoustics modes of cavities, when the speed of wave propagation
reached supersonic levels. This finding, although previously surmised, has been shown in the thesis
and constitutes a major contribution to knowledge.
History
School
Mechanical, Electrical and Manufacturing Engineering
This work is made available according to the conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0) licence. Full details of this licence are available at: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
Publication date
2003
Notes
A Doctoral Thesis. Submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the award of Doctor of Philosophy of Loughborough University.