The use of contextualisation in design evaluation
thesisposted on 05.04.2013, 12:14 authored by Nexon T. Ben
This thesis concerns the study and development of design evaluation methods applicable to conceptual design. The initial research reveals that the techniques and methodologies currently available for evaluation are useful for selecting preferred concepts from a number of candidate solutions during the early conceptual design. However, the later concept development stage does not have well structured techniques or methodologies to assist in evaluation of design proposals as definitive layout drawings are developed. It is clear that the end of the concept development stage is a crucial point in the design process since any design work beyond this point marks the beginning of detail design, incurring higher cost and more limited opportunities for design changes. At this point a structured approach which would help to update the product design specification and enhance the evaluation process by identifying design weaknesses and conflict would lower the risks of ultimate design failure. To achieve this goal, an evaluation technique based on the differentiation of design contexts has been proposed and tested to provide the basis for a design evaluation enhancement method potentially or real value to academia and design practitioners. The work covered in this thesis is based on the hypothesis that evaluation within distinct design contexts will be more effective than use of checklists composed of mixed criteria as currently employed. The hypothesis was tested by experimentation with Masters and PhD engineering design students as participants. This was followed by interviews with experienced designers. Evidence from the tests and interviews supported the hypothesis.
- Mechanical, Electrical and Manufacturing Engineering