posted on 2013-02-11, 11:29authored bySandra L. Lee
Research into the determinants of exercise behaviour and behaviour change
is moving towards more integrated models to expand our understanding of
issues such as why some adults start to exercise and others do not, and why
some relapse from exercise. Accordingly, this thesis takes an exploratory,
realist and constructivist approach to develop such an understanding of the
processes that influence middle-aged adults (non)participation in exercise. A
further intention of the thesis is to reiterate and demonstrate previous calls for
alternative methods of writing by employing a confessional tale in parallel
with the main text which IS used to highlight and make transparent to the
reader those decisions made throughout the research process which are not
always shared with them, but which are important.
A Straussian interpretation of Grounded Theory methodology was adopted to
analyse data from 24 focus groups and 11 individualmterviews with 81
participants aged mainly between 45 and 55 years. Findings identified a
'(re)viewing myself process that explains exercise (non)partlcipation in terms
of the concept of 'self-assessment', which establishes the difference between
'who I am' and 'who I want to be'. A disparity between these may result in an
identity conflict and possible resolution strategies such as change of self
and/or others. In accordance with movements in the research methodology
literature towards theory integration, this process was also related to existing
theories on identity conflict and change, and subsequent hypotheses on the
relationship between identity change and behaviour change are suggested.
The behavioural outcomes of the '(re )viewing myself process led to the
creation of the 'ExerCise Cube', which categorises individuals according to
their exercise perceptions, desires and behaviours. Each aXIs on the cube
representing a continuum, thus a different set of barriers, motivators and
attitudes that require different mterventions if movement across the cube to a
more active identity is to be achieved.
The theoretical and practical implications from this research provide a useful
conceptual tool that can be used practically to inform future interventions that
can be tailored to participants' individual needs. The findings support the
contmued use of more integrated interdisciplinary models and theories in
exercise determinants research.